top of page
Writer's pictureDan Spencer

The Peculiar Truth about the Lenny Dykstra Legal Ruling


  • Lenny Dykstra’s professional sports career was stellar. His life after that became so disreputable that a legal ruling has been named after him.

  • Dykstra played Major League Baseball for the New York Mets (1985-89) and the Philadelphia Phillies (1989-1996). He won a championship with the Mets in 1986 and was named to 3 All-Star teams.

  • Teammates gave him the nickname Nails. No one called him a business genius.

  • 1993: Dykstra had more walks than any other player, he was runner-up for the National League MVP, and his team went to the World Series (but lost to Toronto).

  • After retiring from baseball, Dykstra owned and operated a car wash in his native Southern California. Charges were filed against him, and later dropped, for sexually harassing a teenage employee. When the car wash failed to due Dykstra’s mismanagement, his investors - including many family members - wanted nothing more to do with him.

  • 2005: Dykstra got involved in stock trading thanks to CNBC star Jim Cramer. He let Dykstra write a stock-picking column for his website, and subscribers coughed up nearly $1,000 each annually for his predictions, even though Dykstra had no expertise in such matters.

  • He published a magazine called The Players Club aimed at the promoting the glamorous lives of professional athletes. He owned a jet chartering company. The sky was the limit for Lenny Dykstra.

  • Then everything unraveled.

  • 2007: He purchased the mansion of hockey legend Wayne Gretzky for $18.5 million with the goal of flipping it for a profit. Nobody bought it. Two years later, Dykstra filed for bankruptcy, and the mansion sold at auction.

  • 2009: News reports detailed Dykstra’s business mismanagement. He compiled massive debts and failed to pay for rent or services. His finances were in shambles.

  • 2010: A prostitute accused him of paying for her services with a bounced check.

  • 2011: Dykstra was arrested in California for drug possession, car theft, and identity theft.

  • 2012: He pleaded guilty to federal charges of bankruptcy fraud. He bilked ten creditors out of hundreds of thousands of dollars and served six months in prison.

  • 2015: Dykstra publicly revealed that he spent half a million dollars in 1993 on private detectives to find dirty laundry about Major League umpires. With that secret knowledge, he intimidated umpires into giving him a favorably wider strike zone.

  • 2016: Dykstra appeared twice on Howard Stern’s radio show to promote his personal memoir, and he bragged about being a paid male companion for older women. On the second appearance, he brought two such older women to back him up.

  • 2018: He was arrested in New Jersey after threatening an Uber driver with a gun.

  • The litany of illegal and disreputable occurrences goes on and on.

  • In 2019, Dykstra filed a defamation lawsuit against his former Mets teammate Ron Darling, now a TV baseball analyst. Darling had published his own memoir and cited an incident during the 1986 World Series in which Dykstra hollered racial epithets at a black Red Sox pitcher.

  • Darling’s legal counsel told the court that it was laughable to suggest that anyone could defame Lenny Dykstra given terrible reputation.

  • The judge agreed and stated in his ruling: “Dykstra was infamous for being, among other things, racist, misogynist, and anti-gay, as well as a sexual predator, a drug-abuser, a thief, and an embezzler. Further, Dykstra had a reputation—largely due to his autobiography—of being willing to do anything to benefit himself and his team, including using steroids and blackmailing umpires…”

  • The judge threw out the lawsuit.

  • Some in the news media called it the Lenny Dykstra Rule: You can’t claim defamation of character if your character is already shitty.

  • Today, Dykstra is in his 60s and lives in Los Angeles. According to reports in November 2023, he owed his landlord over $50,000 in back-due rent.

0 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Comentarios


Post: Blog2_Post
bottom of page